The Mustang

Film Comprehension Unit · English Language

The Mustang

Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre · 2019 · Prison drama · Based on real rehabilitation programmes
American English 96 minutes Sundance Film Festival 2019 5 sections

1 · Overview

Film overview

Roman Coleman has spent twelve years in a Nevada state prison for a violent assault on his domestic partner that left her permanently brain-damaged. He does not talk. He does not connect. He tells the prison psychologist simply: "I'm not good with people." When he is assigned to outdoor maintenance, he finds himself drawn to a wild mustang — one of thousands rounded up annually from the American West — that is labelled dangerous and untrainable. He is placed in the prison's horse rehabilitation programme and given twelve weeks to bring the animal from wild to auction-ready. What unfolds is not a story about taming a horse. It is a story about a man who cannot speak his guilt, his grief, or his love for his daughter — and who finds, in an animal equally unable to be reached, a form of communication that words have failed to provide.

The film is rooted in a real programme: the Wild Horse Inmate Program (WHIP), which operates across thirteen American states. Inmates train Bureau of Land Management mustangs that would otherwise face indefinite holding facilities or euthanasia. Research shows participants have significantly lower reoffending rates than the general prison population. Three men in the film were recently released participants in the actual programme — including Thomas Smittle, who said of his own experience: "The horse saved my life."

Director
Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre
Year
2019
Star
Matthias Schoenaerts
Exec. producer
Robert Redford
Accent
American English (Nevada / Western)
Rotten Tomatoes
89% — "powerful performances, tight direction"

Roman and Marquis — a shared portrait

The film's central argument is structural: Roman Coleman and the mustang he names Marquis are the same creature. The parallel is not subtle — it is the film's explicit, sustained metaphor.

Roman Coleman
Taken from his natural environment by his own violence. Held in a facility that cannot reach him. Labelled dangerous. Unable to connect. Cannot be released back into society in his current state. Has a history of harming those closest to him. Is being prepared, with difficulty, for a different kind of life.
Marquis (the mustang)
Taken from his natural environment by government round-up. Held in a facility that cannot reach him. Labelled dangerous and untrainable. Unable to connect. Cannot be released into domestic life in his current state. Responds to pressure with violence. Is being prepared, with difficulty, for sale to a new life.

Historical and social context

Approximately 100,000 wild mustangs roam ten American states, descended from horses brought by Spanish colonisers in the sixteenth century. The Bureau of Land Management conducts annual round-ups using helicopters to manage herd sizes on public land. The rounded-up horses are held in long-term facilities — a system that has been criticised for its cost and the horses' welfare. The Wild Horse Inmate Program offers an alternative: pairing excess horses with inmates who train them for adoption or sale, benefiting both populations.

The film was shot at a former Nevada state prison. De Clermont-Tonnerre — a French director making her feature debut — spent years researching animal therapy programmes in prisons, beginning with a French programme involving small animals. She said she was drawn to the story because it was "about teaching men how to behave and how to reconnect with themselves." She deliberately chose to tell a story about men because, she noted, the programme is currently only available to male inmates: "It really says something about this masculinity and vulnerability."

Characters

RC
Roman Coleman
Inmate, 12 years served for domestic violence assault · Played by Matthias Schoenaerts
The film's near-silent centre. Roman communicates through his body — through violence, through stillness, through the physical acts of care that he can perform for an animal when he cannot perform them for a person. Schoenaerts, a Belgian actor, carries most of the film without dialogue. His performance is one of controlled interior pressure: a man so full of shame and rage that speech has become impossible.
Ma
Marquis
Wild mustang · The film's co-protagonist
Not a symbol — an actual animal with an actual psychology. The film is careful to show the real difficulty of what Roman is attempting: Marquis is terrified, unpredictable, and genuinely dangerous. His gradual trust in Roman is earned through patience and consistency, not sentimentality. The film's greatest achievement is making a horse a full dramatic character.
My
Myles
Head trainer of the horse programme · Played by Bruce Dern
A veteran rancher who has seen many men like Roman — men whose relationship to violence is so ingrained that they do not know they are violent. Myles is not gentle; he is clear. His most important act in the film is expelling Roman from the programme after Roman strikes the horse — and his most important second act is allowing Roman back.
Dr
Dr Gunther
Prison psychologist · Played by Connie Britton
The film's institutional voice of care — limited by the system she works within, but genuinely trying. Her sessions with Roman are the film's closest thing to direct speech about his interior life. She asks the questions; Roman mostly refuses to answer. Her patience without sentimentality gives the film its ethical centre.
MR
Martha
Roman's pregnant teenage daughter · Played by Gideon Adlon
The film's most painful relationship. Martha does not hate her father — which is worse. She has spent years trying to understand why he will not leave prison, why he will not be released, why he seems to choose confinement over her. Her line — "When I was six, I started writing letters to your parole board. Then I understood. You didn't want to get out" — is the film's emotional detonation.
He
Henry
Inmate, experienced horse trainer · Played by Jason Mitchell
Roman's guide into the programme and his first real human connection inside. Henry is the person Roman can almost talk to — the one man whose experience of the world is close enough to his own that communication becomes possible. His death is the film's structural blow: the cost of the prison environment landing on the relationship that was beginning to save Roman.

Key themes

Silence and communication
Roman speaks almost no dialogue. The film asks what can be communicated without words — and what cannot. The horse becomes a language.
Violence and its roots
Roman is not a monster — he is a man whose violence has a history. The film never excuses what he did, but it insists on understanding it.
Rehabilitation and punishment
Does prison rehabilitate — or does it simply contain? The horse programme offers one answer. The drug subplot offers another.
Masculinity and vulnerability
Roman cannot show vulnerability to people. He can show it to a horse. What does this reveal about how men are taught to manage emotion?
Freedom and wildness
The mustang is a symbol of American freedom — wild, uncontainable. The film asks what it means to take that wildness and prepare it for service.
Father and daughter
Roman's relationship with Martha is the human core of the film. His inability to reach her — and his eventual attempt — gives the horse story its emotional stakes.

2 · Vocabulary

Core vocabulary

TermMeaning / How it's used in the film
rehabilitation (n.)The process of helping someone return to a healthy, functioning state after illness, addiction, or imprisonment. The horse programme is officially a rehabilitation programme — the film examines whether it works, and what rehabilitation actually means.
mustang (n.)A free-roaming wild horse of the American West, descended from horses brought by Spanish colonisers in the sixteenth century. In American culture the mustang is a symbol of wildness, freedom, and the untamed West.
domesticate (v.)To tame an animal and adapt it to live with or serve humans. The programme asks Roman to domesticate Marquis — to prepare a wild creature for a human world. The parallel with Roman's own situation is explicit.
solitary confinement (n.)Imprisonment in isolation from other prisoners, as a punishment. Roman is sent to solitary after striking the horse. Solitary is also, the film implies, the condition he has been living in internally for twelve years.
recidivism (n.)The tendency of a convicted criminal to reoffend. Research shows participants in WHIP have lower recidivism rates — one of the programme's key justifications. The film never uses the word but embodies the concept.
auction (n.)A public sale in which goods are sold to the highest bidder. The programme's trained horses are sold at auction to ranchers, police departments, and private buyers. The auction is the film's climactic event and emotional ending point.
round-up (n.)The gathering of livestock or wild animals, typically by helicopter and on horseback. The film opens with Bureau of Land Management round-up footage — the moment the mustang's freedom ends and Roman's story begins.
restorative justice (n.)An approach to justice that focuses on repairing harm rather than simply punishing the offender — often involving confrontation with the impact of one's actions. Roman attends a restorative justice programme alongside the horse work; both ask him to face what he has done.
trauma (n.)A deeply distressing experience and its lasting psychological effects. Both Roman and Marquis are traumatised — and both carry that trauma in their bodies rather than in words. The film treats trauma as something physical, not just psychological.
parole (n./v.)The conditional release of a prisoner before the end of their sentence, subject to continued good behaviour. Roman's parole has been repeatedly denied — a fact the film reveals is partly because Roman himself has refused to engage with the system designed to release him.
to gentle (v.)Horse training term: to calm and accustom a wild horse to human contact through patient, non-violent methods. Myles teaches Roman to "gentle" the horse — a word that the film uses to describe what Roman must also do to himself.
emancipation (n.)The legal process by which a minor becomes legally independent of their parents. Martha visits Roman to obtain his signature for her emancipation — a devastating scene in which a daughter formally separates herself from a father she has never truly had.

Key lines from the film

"I'm not good with people."
Roman's opening self-description to the prison psychologist. It is the film's thesis in five words — and its most carefully chosen understatement. "Not good with people" is Roman's way of saying: I am violent, I am isolated, I have hurt everyone who was close to me, and I have no idea how to stop. The simplicity of the sentence carries an enormous weight of suppressed meaning. Note the negative construction: he does not say what he is, only what he is not. This is Roman's verbal style throughout the film.
"When I was six, I started writing letters of support to your parole board. But your parole was always denied, so I thought it was my fault. Then, when I got older, I understood. You didn't want to get out."
Martha to Roman, in one of their visits. This speech is the film's emotional detonation — delivered quietly by a teenager who has spent her life trying to reach her father and finally understood something devastating about him. The past simple tense ("started," "thought," "understood") gives it the quality of a settled verdict, not an accusation. The final sentence — "You didn't want to get out" — is not angry. It is worse than angry. It is comprehension.
"You hit that horse. You don't hit my horses."
Myles, ejecting Roman from the programme. The possessive "my horses" is the key — this is not an institutional reprimand but a personal one. Myles is not reading from a rulebook; he is making a declaration of protection. The repetition of "hit" — "you hit" / "you don't hit" — mirrors the past act against the absolute rule. It is a sentence with no escape and no appeal. And it is also, for Roman, a mirror: this is what he did to his partner.
"The horse saved my life."
Thomas Smittle, a real participant in the WHIP programme, who appears in the film and served as its consultant. This line — spoken outside the fiction, by a real man — is the film's ultimate statement of purpose. Smittle is training to be a horse trainer. He said this to the director during a research interview when he was still in prison. It is the simplest sentence in the film's orbit and the one that carries the most weight.

Language register in the film

SpeakerRegisterWhat to notice
RomanMinimal, physical, evasiveRoman speaks as little as possible. His sentences are short, declarative, and stripped of any emotional content he is not yet ready to acknowledge. Watch for the moments when he reaches the edge of what he can say — and stops. The silence after his words is often more important than the words themselves.
MarthaControlled, measured, quietly devastatingMartha does not shout. She has grown up learning to manage her own needs carefully. Her language is the language of someone who has spent years preparing what to say to a father who is not really there — rehearsed but genuine. Her calm is the most painful thing about her.
MylesDirect, spare, Western AmericanMyles uses the economical register of someone who has spent decades with animals rather than people. No decoration, no hedging. He gives instructions rather than arguments. When he praises Roman, it is in the same flat register as everything else — which makes it land harder.
Dr GuntherProfessional, patient, carefully indirectA psychologist's register: reflective questions rather than statements, space given for answers that rarely come. She does not tell Roman what he feels — she asks. Her indirectness is a deliberate therapeutic choice, and the film respects it even when it is not enough.
HenryWarm, wry, streetwiseHenry is the only person Roman can relax with slightly. His register is more fluid — prison vernacular, moments of humour, an ease with irony that Roman lacks. His friendship with Roman is partly a language friendship: Henry gives Roman permission to say less and mean more.

Vocabulary task

Without using a dictionary, guess the meaning of these words from their context in the film.

WordMy guess (from context)Confirmed meaning
rehabilitation
to gentle
recidivism
emancipation
restorative justice

3 · Questions

Literal comprehension

Answer using facts directly stated in the film.

1
What crime has Roman committed, and how long has he been in prison when the film begins?
2
How does Roman come to be placed in the horse programme — and what happens when he loses his temper with Marquis?
3
Why does Martha visit Roman — and what does she reveal about her childhood attempts to reach him?
4
What happens to Henry — and what does Roman do in response?
Interpretive comprehension

Think about why characters act as they do.

5
Martha tells Roman she understood — eventually — that he didn't want to get out of prison. What does the film suggest are the reasons for this? Why would a man choose prison over freedom?
6
Roman strikes Marquis in a moment of rage. Myles expels him from the programme. How does this scene mirror Roman's crime — and why is Myles's response important rather than simply punitive?
7
The film suggests Roman can communicate with Marquis in ways he cannot communicate with people. What is it about the horse relationship that makes this possible — and what does the film imply about Roman's capacity for connection?
Critical comprehension

Evaluate and argue. Support your view with evidence.

8
The film never shows us Roman's crime directly. It tells us what happened through description alone. Why might the director have made this choice — and what effect does it have on how we understand and judge Roman?
9
Roman's victim — his partner — is never shown and barely mentioned. She is permanently brain-damaged. The film is entirely about Roman's journey. Is this a problem — does the film ask us to invest emotionally in a man at the expense of the woman he hurt?
10
The film ends at the auction — Roman has prepared Marquis for a new life and invited Martha to witness it. Is this a satisfying ending? What has Roman actually changed — and what has not changed at all?
Creative response

Choose one. Write 150–250 words.

Option A
Write Martha's diary entry on the evening after attending the auction. She has watched her father present a horse he has trained. She is pregnant, she is alone, and something has shifted between them — though nothing is resolved. Write in her voice.
Option B
Write the session notes that Dr Gunther might write after Roman's final session with her — capturing what she observes about his progress, what she remains uncertain about, and what the horse programme has done that her therapy alone could not.

4 · Language

The Mustang is one of the most linguistically sparse films in recent American cinema. Its protagonist barely speaks. Its most important scenes contain almost no dialogue. Studying the film's language means studying what is communicated in the near-absence of words — through silence, through gesture, through the physical language of man and horse — and asking what this sparseness reveals about Roman's interior life.

Scene-by-scene language analysis

Scene 1 · Opening session "I'm not good with people" — the weight of understatement
Dr Gunther
"Tell me something about yourself."
Roman
"I'm not good with people."
Understatement as self-protection
"I'm not good with people" is one of the great cinematic understatements. Beneath it: I committed an act of devastating violence against the person I was supposed to love most. I have spent twelve years refusing to engage with any system designed to release or help me. I cannot speak to my daughter. I strike things I cannot control. Roman reduces all of this to a social inadequacy. The gap between what the sentence says and what it means is the whole film.
The negative construction
"Not good with people" — Roman defines himself by absence and negation throughout the film. He tells us what he is not, what he cannot do, what he does not feel — never what he is. This grammatical pattern reveals something about how shame operates: it is easier to describe a lack than to claim an identity. Roman has no positive self-description available.
Dr Gunther's response
She does not push. She accepts the statement and finds a practical solution: outdoor maintenance rather than group work. This is therapeutic pragmatism — working with where someone is rather than where you need them to be. Her patience without sentimentality models the same quality the horse programme will later require of Roman.
Scene 2 · The round pen Non-verbal communication — a new language
Scene description
Roman and Marquis in the round pen. No dialogue. Roman attempts to approach; Marquis retreats. Roman holds out his hand; the horse shies. Roman is still; Marquis is still. Gradually, across many attempts, across many sessions, the distance closes.
The language of pressure and release
Horse training uses what trainers call "pressure and release" — you apply gentle directional pressure, and when the horse responds in the right direction, you release the pressure as a reward. This is entirely non-verbal. Roman, who has used violence (extreme pressure with no release) in his human relationships, must learn a completely different grammar: small pressure, consistent release, patience, consistency. The horse is teaching him a language he has never spoken.
Stillness as communication
The most important thing Roman learns is how to be still. With people, his body has been a threat. With the horse, stillness signals safety. When Roman becomes still and the horse approaches him, the film has achieved something it cannot achieve through dialogue — a demonstration that Roman is capable of being safe. This is a communication that his twelve years of sessions with Dr Gunther have not been able to produce.
For discussion
Can we communicate things through physical presence that we cannot communicate through words? Think of other situations — with children, with animals, with people in grief or fear — where non-verbal communication is more truthful than what we could say. What does the film suggest about why Roman finds this language easier?
Scene 3 · Martha's visit Spoken truth — the language Roman cannot answer
Martha
"When I was six, I started writing letters of support to your parole board. But your parole was always denied, so I thought it was my fault that you were still in prison, because I wasn't a good enough writer. Then, when I got older, I understood. You didn't want to get out. So I stopped writing. I kept one of those letters. 'My dad is fun.'"
The past simple as verdict
Martha's entire speech is in the past simple tense — "started," "thought," "understood," "stopped," "kept." This is the tense of completed action, of settled understanding. She is not asking Roman to explain himself; she has already done the work of understanding. The past simple closes doors. Roman has nothing to enter through because Martha has already arrived at her conclusion without him.
The child's letter
"My dad is fun." Three words in the present simple — the tense of timeless fact — from a six-year-old who believed in a father she had never really known. This fragment is placed at the end of Martha's speech like a weapon. She does not comment on it. She does not need to. The gap between "My dad is fun" and everything she has just described is where the film's grief lives.
Roman's response
Roman says almost nothing. This is the pattern: Martha uses language with precision and courage; Roman falls silent. But something has landed. The next scenes show a change in his behaviour — he invites Martha to the auction, he begins to work with a purpose beyond his own survival. The spoken truth reaches him even when he cannot respond to it.

Grammar in context

StructureHow it appearsWhy it matters
Understatement and negative construction
"I'm not good with people."
Roman's self-descriptions consistently use negation — he describes what he is not rather than what he is. This grammatical pattern reflects his relationship to self-knowledge: shame makes direct self-description impossible.Understatement — saying less than the situation warrants — is one of the most culturally specific speech acts in American English. Recognising it requires understanding context, history, and what is being suppressed.
Past simple as verdict
"Then I understood. You didn't want to get out."
Martha uses the past simple for conclusions she has already reached. The tense signals that her understanding is complete — she is not still working through it, she has arrived.Tense carries emotional and epistemic information — it tells us not just when something happened, but the speaker's relationship to it. Past simple for a personal realisation signals closure; present simple would signal ongoing uncertainty.
Imperative in training language
"Easy. Stand. Easy now."
Myles's instructions to Roman — and Roman's eventual words to Marquis — are single-word imperatives. This is the grammar of horse training: minimal, consistent, clear. The same commands, in the same tone, every time.Imperatives are commands — but in horse training they function as reassurance. The same word repeated consistently tells the horse what to predict. Consistency is the grammar of safety. This is what Roman must learn to provide.
Silence as speech act
[No dialogue — only physical presence and movement]
The film's most important scenes contain no dialogue. Roman's relationship with Marquis, his progress through the programme, his internal change — all are communicated without words.A speech act is any communicative action that performs a function — it does not have to be spoken. Silence, stillness, a held-out hand — all function as speech acts with specific communicative force. The film asks us to read these as carefully as we read dialogue.
Present simple for timeless truth
"My dad is fun." / "The horse saved my life."
The child Martha's letter and Thomas Smittle's real-life testimony both use the present simple — the tense of things that are simply true, always, without qualification.The present simple strips away time and context to make a statement of fact. "My dad is fun" is heartbreaking precisely because it is in the present simple — it does not say "was," it says "is," which means the six-year-old believed in a permanent truth she was already wrong about.

Language and film features

①
The film's silence — what dialogue cannot do
The Mustang makes a formal argument through its own sparseness: some things cannot be said in words, and the attempt to say them in words would make them smaller. Roman's transformation is shown, not told. The scenes in the round pen, the gradual closing of physical distance between man and horse, the moment when Roman's body first becomes still rather than tense — these communicate something that a therapist's report or a courtroom confession could not. This is what cinema can do that other media cannot: show internal change in real time, without commentary.
②
The Western landscape as language
The film is set in Nevada — desert, mountains, open sky — and the landscape does constant work. The world outside the prison fence is vast, wild, and indifferent. The prison is a small human enclosure inside it. Cinematographer Ruben Impens frames Roman as a tiny figure against enormous landscape — which mirrors both his smallness in the system and the scale of what the mustang represents: freedom, America, wildness that cannot be completely tamed. The landscape is not decoration; it is an argument about containment and what lies outside it.
③
Schoenaerts's body as language
Matthias Schoenaerts delivers almost all of his performance without dialogue. His body is the text: the set of his shoulders, the way he holds his hands, the specific quality of his stillness versus his tension. In the early scenes his physicality is threatening — large, coiled, unpredictable. In the later scenes it gradually changes: the same body becomes capable of gentleness, of patience, of stillness that communicates safety rather than danger. Watching this transformation requires the audience to read physical language as carefully as spoken language.
④
A French director's American English
The film was made by a French director — Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre — with a Belgian lead actor, in an American setting. This outsider perspective shapes the film in specific ways. De Clermont-Tonnerre approached the prison and the West with the curiosity of someone not raised in American culture — more attentive to what is strange, more patient with what she does not immediately understand. The result is an American film that feels more European in its restraint, its tolerance for silence, and its refusal to explain itself. Notice the absence of the big speech, the dramatic confrontation, the cathartic breakdown — conventions of American cinema that this film deliberately withholds.

Language tasks

Task A — Reading silence
Choose two scenes in the film where little or no dialogue is spoken. For each: describe what you think Roman is communicating through his body language, his movement, or his stillness. What specific physical signals does Schoenaerts use? What would be lost if the director had added dialogue to explain the scene?
Task B — The language of Martha's speech
Analyse Martha's speech about the parole board letters. Identify: (1) the tense she uses and why; (2) the structural movement from child's belief to adult's understanding; (3) why she ends with the phrase "My dad is fun" rather than something that directly condemns her father. What does each of these choices reveal about her character — and about what she still feels?
Task C — Understatement and what it hides
"I'm not good with people" is a profound understatement. Write what Roman might say if he could speak honestly about himself — without the protection of understatement, without the armour of minimal language. Then explain: why is Roman's version — the understatement — actually more true to who he is than the honest version would be?

5 · Activities

Before viewing

TaskWhat to do
Wild Horse Inmate ProgramFind out: What is the Wild Horse Inmate Program? In how many states does it operate? What does research say about its effect on reoffending rates? Note three facts.
The mustang in American cultureFind out: What are American mustangs — where do they come from historically, and how many exist today? What does the mustang symbolise in American culture? Note three facts.
Domestic violenceResearch briefly: what proportion of domestic violence cases result in permanent injury? How does the justice system typically respond? You do not need specific statistics — just a general understanding of scale and consequence.
DiscussionCan a person who has committed a violent crime be rehabilitated? Is punishment about changing the offender, protecting society, or making the victim feel justice has been done? Discuss in pairs — there is no single right answer.

While viewing

TaskInstructions
Silence logNote five moments where important communication happens without words. For each: what is being communicated, and how?
Roman and Marquis parallelNote three specific moments where Roman's situation mirrors Marquis's. What detail in each links them?
Martha scenesNote what Martha says in each of her visits. How does her language change across the film — and what does she give Roman that no one else does?
The victimNote every reference to Roman's victim — the woman he assaulted. How many times is she mentioned? How is she described? What does her near-absence tell us about where the film places its attention?

After viewing

TaskInstructions
Class discussionDoes the film ask us to feel too much sympathy for Roman at the expense of his victim? Is it possible to tell a story of rehabilitation honestly — without erasing the harm that made rehabilitation necessary?
Film reviewWrite a film review (150–200 words) that engages with both the film's emotional power and its ethical complexity. Avoid either simply praising it or dismissing it.
Essay question"The Mustang suggests that some people can only communicate love through action, not words. Do you agree — and does Roman's relationship with Marquis prove this, or merely demonstrate it?" Write 250–300 words using specific evidence from the film.

Assessment grid — film review

CriterionExcellentGoodNeeds work
Engages with emotional power and ethical complexityBoth addressed with specific evidenceOne aspect dominant; other briefly mentionedOnly emotional response or only ethical judgement
Specific evidence from the film2+ specific scenes or lines cited1 example usedGeneral claims only
Vocabulary: uses words from the unit5+ unit words used correctly3–4 unit words usedFewer than 3 unit words
Language: grammar and registerConsistent formal register; minimal errorsMostly clear; some errorsErrors impede meaning
Length: 150–200 words150–200 words130–149 or 201–220Under 130 or over 220
The Mustang · Film Comprehension Unit · English Language
Scroll to Top