On the Basis of Sex
1 · Overview
Film overview
On the Basis of Sex follows Ruth Bader Ginsburg from her first year at Harvard Law School in 1956 to her first major courtroom victory in 1972. The film traces her struggle to be taken seriously as a lawyer at a time when most firms refused to hire women, her years as a law professor teaching sex discrimination law without yet being able to practise it, and the case that changed her career: Moritz v. Commissioner. Charles Moritz, an unmarried man, had been denied a tax deduction for hiring a caretaker for his elderly mother — a deduction that a single woman in the same situation would have received automatically. Ruth and her husband Marty Ginsburg, a tax attorney, took the case together and argued it before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. They won. The case became the foundation of Ginsburg's strategy for dismantling sex discrimination in American law.
The screenplay was written by Daniel Stiepleman — Ginsburg's own nephew. Ginsburg read the first three drafts. She had two conditions for the film: get the law right, and get Marty right. Ginsburg herself described the film as "part fact, part imaginative — but what's wonderful about it is that the imaginative parts fit in with the story so well."
Historical context
When Ruth Bader Ginsburg started at Harvard Law School in 1956, she was one of only nine women in a class of over 500. Dean Erwin Griswold famously asked each of the nine women at a dinner to justify taking a place from a qualified man. Despite graduating top of her class at Columbia (after transferring), she was turned down by every law firm she applied to. The reason, as she later put it: "ethnicity, sex, and motherhood trumped other attributes."
Ginsburg's legal strategy was deliberate and methodical. She understood that for sex discrimination to be struck down constitutionally, a series of precedents had to be built — just as Thurgood Marshall had built the legal framework that enabled Brown v. Board of Education in 1954. The Moritz case was chosen partly because the plaintiff was a man — making it harder for an all-male judiciary to dismiss the case as female self-interest. Ginsburg later went on to argue six landmark gender discrimination cases before the Supreme Court, winning five.
Characters
Key themes
2 · Vocabulary
Legal vocabulary
| Term | Meaning / How it's used in the film |
|---|---|
| discrimination (n.) | Unjust treatment of a person based on a characteristic such as sex, race, or religion. The film focuses specifically on sex discrimination — laws that treat men and women differently based on assumed social roles. |
| unconstitutional (adj.) | In conflict with the principles set out in a country's constitution. The Ginsburgs argue that Section 214 of the tax code is unconstitutional because it treats people differently based on sex, violating the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. |
| precedent (n.) | A previous court decision that guides or binds future decisions on the same legal question. Ginsburg's strategy was to build a series of precedents — small victories that together would make larger ones possible. |
| plaintiff (n.) | The person who brings a case to court. Charles Moritz is the plaintiff in Moritz v. Commissioner — a choice Ginsburg made deliberately because a male plaintiff was harder for a male judiciary to dismiss. |
| oral argument (n.) | A spoken presentation of a legal case before a court of appeal. The climax of the film is Ruth's oral argument before the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. It is her first time arguing in an appellate court. |
| equal protection (n.) | A constitutional principle requiring that no person be denied the same protection of the law as others in similar circumstances. The 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause is the constitutional hook for Ginsburg's argument. |
| brief (n.) | A written document submitted to a court before oral argument, laying out a party's legal arguments and evidence. Ruth writes the legal brief for Moritz — a document so thorough that when the government analyses it, they find it challenges hundreds of existing statutes. |
| statute (n.) | A formal written law passed by a legislature. The government's computer analysis reveals that striking down Section 214 would challenge over 170 federal statutes — which is exactly Ginsburg's wider aim. |
| appellate court (n.) | A court that reviews decisions made by lower courts. The Moritz case goes to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals — the level below the Supreme Court. |
| to litigate (v.) | To take legal action; to argue a case in court. The ACLU agrees to finance the litigation of the Moritz case — covering the legal costs of taking it through the court system. |
| deduction (n.) | An amount subtracted from taxable income, reducing the tax owed. Moritz was denied a tax deduction for hiring a caretaker for his elderly mother — a deduction a woman in the same situation would have received. |
| hagiographic (adj.) | Describing someone in an excessively admiring way, like a saint's biography. Several critics called the film "hagiographic" — presenting Ginsburg so positively that it loses complexity. This is worth debating. |
Key lines from the film
Language register in the film
| Speaker/context | Register | What to notice |
|---|---|---|
| Ruth (professional) | Precise, formal, controlled | Ruth's professional register is a deliberate performance — she knows that any emotional outburst will be used against her. Her sentences are complete, her vocabulary exactly chosen. Compare with how she speaks at home. |
| Ruth (domestic) | Warmer, more direct, occasionally wry | At home with Marty, Ruth's language is more relaxed. The film uses this contrast to show her full range — and to show what she suppresses in professional settings. |
| Dean Griswold | Academic, paternalistic, certain | Griswold speaks with the confidence of an institution that has never had to justify itself. His register is inclusive-sounding ("all of us") while excluding ("a spot from a qualified man"). Listen for how his certainty is encoded in his grammar. |
| Marty Ginsburg | Charming, self-deprecating, warm | Marty uses social warmth as a tool — he can navigate rooms Ruth finds hostile. He uses humour, self-deprecation, and apparent informality to defuse tension. His register is less guarded than Ruth's because society is less guarded towards him. |
| Government attorney Bozarth | Procedural, rhetorical, political | Bozarth frames the Ginsburgs' argument as a threat to "the American way of life" — escalating the register from legal to political. This is a rhetorical tactic: when you cannot win on the legal argument, broaden the frame. Listen for how Ruth refuses this escalation. |
Vocabulary task
Without using a dictionary, guess the meaning of these words from their context in the film.
| Word | My guess (from context) | Confirmed meaning |
|---|---|---|
| precedent | ||
| unconstitutional | ||
| plaintiff | ||
| to litigate | ||
| hagiographic |
3 · Questions
Answer using facts directly stated in the film.
Think about why characters act as they do.
Evaluate and argue. Support your view with evidence.
Choose one. Write 150–250 words.
4 · Language
On the Basis of Sex is a film built on the power of precise language — in courtrooms, in lecture halls, and at kitchen tables. Ginsburg's legal strategy was a language strategy: choose the right words, the right frame, the right case, and the law could be moved. The film is also a study in how institutional language excludes, and how a precise counterargument can dismantle that exclusion.
Scene-by-scene language analysis
Grammar in context
| Structure | How it appears | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Presupposition in questions "Why are you taking the place of a man?" | Griswold's dinner question contains a presupposition — that law school is for men, and women's presence is a displacement. The question cannot be answered without accepting this premise unless the respondent challenges the frame. | Recognising presuppositions — assumptions embedded in questions — is a key critical thinking skill in debate, law, and everyday conversation. |
| Reductio ad absurdum "Nor does the word 'freedom.'" | Ruth uses her opponent's own logic to expose its absurdity: if the absence of a word means the absence of a right, then freedom itself would be unprotected by the Constitution. | Reductio ad absurdum — showing that a position leads to an obviously unacceptable conclusion — is a classic and powerful form of logical argument. |
| Negation before affirmation "I do not ask this court to change society. I ask the law to catch up." | Ruth consistently denies the opponent's framing before offering her own. The negative construction first ("I do not...") clears the space; the positive statement ("I ask...") fills it with her own meaning. | This structure — negate, then affirm — is a fundamental rhetorical pattern. It is harder to dismiss than a simple positive claim because it explicitly addresses the counter-argument. |
| The passive voice as evasion "Women have traditionally been excluded from..." | Characters who defend the status quo use passive constructions — things happened, exclusions were made, but nobody in particular is responsible. Ginsburg consistently uses active constructions when naming injustice: someone did this, and it was wrong. | Passive voice removes human agency. When institutions describe injustice in the passive voice, they conceal who is responsible. Learning to identify this is a crucial critical reading skill. |
| Parallelism in argument "Patient. Methodical. Strategic." | Ruth and others use parallel structures — lists of single words, matched clauses — to give arguments rhetorical force. The parallel structure implies that items are equivalent in importance and weight. | Parallel structure is a fundamental rhetorical device. In spoken argument, it creates rhythm and memorability; in written argument, it signals balance and precision. |
Language features
Language tasks
5 · Activities
Before viewing
| Task | What to do |
|---|---|
| Legal context | Find out: What is the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause? What was Thurgood Marshall's legal strategy in Brown v. Board of Education — and why did Ginsburg study it? Note three facts. |
| Harvard Law School 1956 | Research what Harvard Law School was like for women in 1956: when were women first admitted, how many were in the class, and what careers were open to them after graduation? Note three facts. |
| Discussion | Is the law a good tool for achieving social change — or does law always follow society rather than lead it? Discuss in pairs, then share your view with the class. |
| Vocabulary preview | Look at the legal vocabulary on the Vocabulary tab. Which five words do you think will appear most often in the film? Choose them and explain your reasoning. |
While viewing
| Task | Instructions |
|---|---|
| Presupposition log | Note three moments where a character's language contains a hidden assumption. Write the line and identify the assumption. |
| Register contrast | Note one example of Ruth's professional register and one of her domestic register. What is different — vocabulary, sentence length, tone? |
| The Marty question | Note three things Marty does in the film that challenge conventional gender expectations. How does the film present these — as remarkable, or as simply what equality looks like? |
| Strategy tracker | Each time Ruth makes a deliberate strategic choice rather than an emotional one, note it. What choices does she make, and what does the film suggest she gives up each time? |
After viewing
| Task | Instructions |
|---|---|
| Class discussion | Is Ginsburg's approach — patient, methodical, educational — the right way to fight injustice? Or are there situations where confrontation and emotion are not just acceptable but necessary? |
| Critical essay | Write a critical essay (250–350 words): "On the Basis of Sex presents Ruth Bader Ginsburg as a near-perfect heroine. Is this a strength or a weakness of the film?" |
| Essay question | "The film argues that real change comes from working within institutions, not against them. Do you agree — with the film, or with that argument?" Write 250–300 words using evidence from the film and your own knowledge. |
Assessment grid — critical essay
| Criterion | Excellent | Good | Needs work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Argument: clear position on the film's approach | Strong, nuanced position maintained throughout | Position stated but inconsistently argued | No clear position |
| Evidence: uses specific scenes and lines | Multiple specific examples from the film | Some examples; underdeveloped | General claims without evidence |
| Vocabulary: uses words from the unit | 5+ unit words used correctly | 3–4 unit words used | Fewer than 3 unit words |
| Language: grammar and formal register | Consistent formal register; minimal errors | Mostly clear; some errors | Errors impede meaning |
| Critical thinking: engages with counter-arguments | Counter-argument genuinely considered before concluding | Counter-argument acknowledged briefly | One-sided throughout |